The failure of a justice system is that we have formed the mindset that the imprisoned is being ‘punished’ for their actions. That should not be the conclusion, as in this case most won’t even think of this guy after awhile.
What is missed is that there is no preventive image to cause others to not do the same. The results of someones actions that causes incarceration should be the deterrence we need it to be. But when that is the final thought and the punishment disappears behind walls, it is no longer a deterrence.
I’m not sure I’m ready to endorse public display of punishment but I remember a book about the women who made the trek across this country on wagon trains. The book was a collection of letters home and in one of them the woman writer recounted the occurrence of a member of the ‘train’ who shot a young Indian girl sitting on a tree stump just observing the ‘white people’ strangers.
The Tribe forced the travelers to hand the man who did it over, and then while demanding the entire collection of white people, children and all, to be present, they tied the man to a pole and two elders of the Tribe skinned him alive. The image of the man being cut loose and running to a nearby river and throwing himself in the water, probably left a strong image on those people to not mess with Indian children.
Prison does nothing to deter crime… it’s just where we hide away what we can’t stomach.